Important NSA Update: September 2025

Aetna “Dummy Codes” Settlement and Horizon CMS Technical Assistance Non-Payment Letters

Horizon BCBS has begun sending out letters impacting hundreds of NSA determinations stating that they will not be paying the NSA awards. We believe their position to be meritless, and we are in the process of opposing it in the strongest terms possible. We are notifying the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance (NJ DOBI) as well as CMS of Horizon’s blatantly improper position. We will be filing complaints with those agencies, drafting a letter to Horizon, and continuing to file federal lawsuits against Horizon (and other carriers) to compel the payment of overdue NSA awards.

There was also a recently announced class action settlement in a noteworthy case. The filings alleged that Aetna hid its vendor’s (Optum’s) administrative costs by creating “dummy CPT codes” and concealing Optum’s administrative costs on patient EOBs by making it look as if Optum’s administrative costs were, in fact, medical expenses. After a decade of litigation and an appellate court ruling that such conduct was a breach of fiduciary duty, the case is settling for $8.4M to the plaintiff class.

If you would like to receive future G&G No Surprises Act updates, or know someone who should, sign up HERE.

Questions about how any of this affects your practice? Contact James Greenspan at JGreenspan@GottliebandGreenspan.com.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

No Comment
Leave a Comment