Departments Deny Recertification of Two Federal IDR Entities
The Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor, and Treasury announced on November 4, 2026 that two certified Federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) entities, Island Peer Review Organization (IPRO) and Network Medical Review Company, have been denied recertification to continue participating in the Federal IDR process under the No Surprises Act.
According to the CMS announcement, the Departments determined that both entities failed to meet the minimum performance standards required of certified IDR entities. As a result, IPRO and Network Medical Review Company may no longer accept new disputes under the Federal IDR process. Both entities have the right to appeal the denial within 30 business days of the Departments’ written denial notice, and the Departments will not issue a final denial until that appeal period has run and any appeals have been considered.
IDR entity certifications must be reviewed and renewed every five years under the No Surprises Act. The remaining eight certified IDR entities that applied for recertification, which include C2C Innovative Solutions, Federal Hearings and Appeals Services, Keystone Peer Review Organization (Acentra), Maximus Federal Services, MCMC Services, Medical Evaluators of Texas, National Medical Reviews, and ProPeer Resources, remain under review following the close of the public petition periods. A future announcement will be made regarding the status of those applications.
What Does This Mean for Providers?
For providers currently engaged in the Federal IDR process, the immediate question is what impact, if any, this decision will have on pending disputes.
On November 5, CMS began sending notices directly to parties with open disputes at the two entities. Based on that guidance, providers with open disputes assigned to either entity should not expect an immediate disruption. Although IPRO and Network Medical Review Company are no longer accepting new disputes, they will continue working on disputes currently assigned to them until their certifications expire on December 31, 2026.
If any disputes remain unresolved at that point, those disputes will be reassigned to another certified IDR entity. The Departments have indicated that additional information regarding the reassignment process and next steps will be provided at that time.
In the meantime, deadlines on open disputes with IPRO or Network Medical Review Company still apply, so continue to respond to offer and information requests on time. Payment determinations these entities have already issued are not affected by the announcement, and carriers remain obligated to pay those awards within 30 business days.
Our Take
This is the first time the Departments have declined to recertify a certified IDR entity, and it did not happen in a vacuum. In late October, the Coalition Against Surprise Medical Billing and the ERISA Industry Committee, both carrier and employer groups, sent letters urging the Departments to pause recertification and apply tougher scrutiny to the arbitrators. IPRO in particular had drawn press coverage for ruling in favor of providers more often than any other IDR entity. Insurers applauded the decision to terminate them within a day.
The Departments have not said which standards the two entities failed to meet. The regulations cover timeliness, accuracy, and independence and impartiality, and the announcement cites all three without singling one out. What we do know is that the two entities removed were among those that ruled for providers most often, while the eight still under review include entities our clients have had far more trouble with. We will be watching those decisions closely.
The practical concern for providers is where reassigned disputes land. Outcomes vary meaningfully from one IDR entity to the next, and a dispute pending at IPRO in December will be decided by a different entity in 2027. We also expect some carriers to point to this announcement as a reason to delay or challenge awards IPRO and Network Medical Review Company already issued. Nothing in the announcement supports that. A payment determination is binding when issued, and we do not read a later denial of recertification as a basis to reopen it.
Gottlieb & Greenspan will continue to monitor developments and provide updates as additional guidance becomes available. For clients whose IDR disputes we manage, we are identifying every open dispute assigned to IPRO or Network Medical Review Company and will track them through any reassignment. No action is needed on your part.
You can view the full announcement on the CMS website: Federal IDR Notices
If you would like to receive future G&G No Surprises Act updates, or know someone who should, sign up HERE.
Questions about how any of this affects your practice? Contact James Greenspan at JGreenspan@GottliebandGreenspan.com.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.


